Swing research directory Walkthroughs Evidence checks Approach Questions Swing research directory

Trade Ideas assessment

Scanning and alert research

Potential candidate-discovery tooling; confirm whether a particular rule suits a multi-day workflow.

Documentation-based research revised 7 October 2026. These assessments are not paid-account tests, audited follower returns or a leaderboard assembled from user ratings.

Discovery versus holding

Trade Ideas' guide describes its tools, but a scanner event does not supply every decision needed for a swing trade. Name the selected alert and the rule governing how long an idea remains actionable.

Observation test

Keep a forward list including candidates that were never traded, not only charts of later winners. A scanner assessed for intraday use should not acquire a multi-day record merely by extending selected historical trades. We have not validated swing-specific returns or instrument access.

Sources

Compare the product categories

Carry the candidate identity into the journal

When an idea begins in a scanning or decision-support workflow, retain its candidate identity and the later instruction that actually initiated exposure. Do not turn every generated candidate into a closed trade or omit candidates solely because they did not develop into an entry. For the positions you did enter, preserve quantities, costs and the rule governing later changes. The new workflow comparison guide distinguishes candidate, instruction and account populations so a comparison does not mix them into one apparently precise hit fraction.

Worked swing records and calculators