Swing research directory Walkthroughs Evidence checks Approach Questions Swing research directory

A consecutive swing-alert journal

Track original ideas, modifications, open exposure and missed entries without giving hindsight permission to choose the best fills.

One identifier per idea

Assign a stable identifier when the original alert arrives. Keep the author, instrument, version, declared time, delivery time and the entry's validity window on that row. Later changes should reference the identifier and preserve their own chronology. Do not count a revised target as a new successful alert while forgetting the original idea's loss.

Record statuses honestly

Use explicit states such as observed, actionable, ordered, partly filled, filled, cancelled, expired and closed. A missed entry is not automatically a losing strategy signal, but neither is it a subscriber win. Keep the provider's reconstructed outcome and the buyer's account outcome in separate columns. Open positions should remain open at the period cutoff rather than being priced at a convenient future date.

Retain the holding rule

Write whether the clock is based on elapsed calendar days, completed sessions or another stated rule. Mark holidays and the first day of actual exposure. A 'two-week' statement without a clock can become ambiguous across a long closure. If a time stop changes during the sample, preserve the earlier rule and label the resulting segment rather than rewriting the history under the new version.

Add overlap before averaging

Maintain a dated list of simultaneous open ideas and note shared industry, market or event exposure where it is known. Counts alone do not estimate portfolio loss, but they show why per-alert returns are not simply account returns. Record the actual allocation separately. Avoid arithmetic that assumes every alert receives the entire account or that concurrent returns can be compounded one after another.

A usable review packet

Save original messages, change records, the declared evaluation rules and any broker evidence under a dated manifest. Include rows with no execution and questions still unresolved. A reviewer should be able to follow one idea through the whole lifecycle and reconcile the number of observations without guessing what was deleted. This is an organisational method, not a claim that the desk has received or certified a provider's complete packet.

Sources

Swing gap scenario worksheet | Source-linked assessments

Distinguish a new idea from a quantity change

Give the original idea a stable position ID. An amendment can change the instruction attached to that position without creating another independent trade. A partial reduction changes remaining quantity; an additional entry lot introduces another price and potentially another fee. The teaching journal intentionally excludes additions so its conservation rule is simple: original quantity equals exited plus remaining quantity. A real ledger with additions needs explicit lot identities. A series of notifications alone does not establish how much exposure is still open.

Worked swing records and calculators