Overnight gaps and swing-alert instructions
A practical audit of original entries, later changes and next-session exits, with gaps kept separate from promised stop prices.
Write the instruction before the gap
A swing idea needs more than a direction and a chart. Retain the tradable instrument, entry condition, validity window, exit policy and time zone in the original message. If a provider later changes the stop, save the new instruction with its arrival time rather than editing the original row. That chronology determines which version a buyer could have followed. An attractive final chart is not enough to reconstruct the decision when instructions changed during a closed session or after a market-moving announcement.
Separate a trigger from an execution
FINRA warns that stop orders do not guarantee the stop price when triggered, while a stop-limit may remain unfilled. Apply that distinction to the actual order type and broker. Do not show a planned $95 stop as an executed $95 exit unless a record supports it. In a deliberately hypothetical long example, ten linear units entered at $100 and exiting at $92 lose $80 before fees. An exit at the intended $95 price would lose $50 before fees. The difference describes a scenario, not the observed performance of a service.
Check the session boundary
Identify the exchange calendar, next opening time and whether the account can trade the selected instrument outside regular hours. Investor.gov's extended-hours bulletin describes liquidity, spread and execution concerns. A quote outside the main session may not mean the buyer could execute the full intended quantity there. Keep the usable order route separate from the provider's chosen chart source. If the signal assumes an unavailable session, record the instruction as incompatible with the tested account instead of manufacturing a fill.
Make event handling explicit
For an earnings release, corporate announcement or other scheduled event, ask whether the rule maintains, reduces or closes exposure, and when that instruction must arrive. A provider does not need to predict the event correctly to have a clear policy. Conversely, a provider's later explanation does not prove the policy existed beforehand. Preserve the event source and its known publication time. This checklist is an evidence request, not a rule saying every buyer should exit before every announcement.
Keep costs on the same clock
Multi-day costs need dates as well as prices. Record the carrying or financing convention appropriate to the instrument, any currency conversion and applicable fees. Do not treat a hypothetical long-stock example as a universal calculation for borrowed shares, options or futures. The swing worksheet uses linear USD units and user-entered carrying costs; it deliberately does not model option Greeks, borrow availability or contract multipliers. An accurate comparison begins by acknowledging when its arithmetic does not cover the actual position.
Watch the whole open book
Several positions may respond to the same broad event even when their ticker names differ. Keep simultaneous exposure visible in the journal rather than analysing every alert as if it were the only trade. A provider's per-signal win rate cannot describe the experience of holding overlapping positions through a gap. Separate an observation of correlation from a portfolio sizing recommendation: this site does not know the reader's account, loss capacity or existing holdings, and does not tell them how much to allocate.
Judge a forward sequence
Choose a dated observation window and retain every instruction, change, cancellation and unresolved idea within it. Distinguish a completed loss, a missed message, a rejected order and an unfilled entry. Do not remove unresolved positions simply because the subscription trial ended. Compare the documented rule with this sequence before reaching a conclusion about suitability. A complete retained sample can support more useful questions than selected screenshots, but a short sample still does not certify future profitability or prove an account could repeat the historical path.
Sources
One scenario price does not establish availability
The new basket exercise takes a supplied adverse exit for each position and applies linear price arithmetic. It does not infer whether that price was tradable or whether an instruction arrived before it. Those questions need the market session, order terms and delivery history. Keep the planned stop price alongside the scenario exit, not inside the same field. The packet's difference is an arithmetic comparison of assumptions, useful for understanding sensitivity but not proof of an actual gap loss or an executable worst case.